UX Collective

We believe designers are thinkers as much as they are makers. https://linktr.ee/uxc

Follow publication

Butterflies, not moon shots

blue butterflies on pink brick background
Credit: @_drz_, Unsplash

A “butterfly” is a flexible idea that can easily move around and adapt to different situations, spreading awareness and inspiring new actions. Just like real pollinators, butterflies are ideas and concepts that are designed to fertilize and generate a new wave of growth. Moving around all areas of a system, they regenerate themselves by leaving traces of an idea that can be adopted by the receiver. It’s hard to know an idea came from the pollinator; they are eventually lost in a sea of similar ideas.

A couple of examples of butterflies:

  • open-source knowledge,
  • flexible solutions like checklists where the idea is naturally customized and becomes your own. I might suggest you start using a checklist for your work, but you’re the person who writes it.

Butterflies are a major departure from the capitalist “moon shot” concept. A moon shot is a single idea with the goal of disrupting a market, dominating and winning over space. You want to build the best product, that will ‘wipe out’ your competition. But if you really think about it, the behaviour of a moon shot sounds a lot like an invasive weed.

a graphic of butterflies, explaining that butterflies facilitate big systems change by spreading accessible ideas. you move from anxious to confident, from focused on our action to focused on community action, and from centralized management to distributed management

On the contrary, regenerative design hopes to create concepts and interventions that regenerate and become ‘invisible’ through broad uptake and evolution. They are flexible and adapt to their environment to avoid disruption. When we look at a field of flowers blooming, we do not know which pollinators are responsible for each individual flower. Unacknowledged for their individual contribution by outsiders looking in, the celebration of the pollinator is the shared joy of the flowered field.

“It’s amazing what you can accomplish when you don’t care who gets the credit.” — Harry S. Truman

Biomimicry and regenerative design move from the position that our creativity, our processes, and technologies can and should be inspired by nature. In line with the idea that “there are no new ideas,” nature has infinite patterns, formulas, and answers for us. And so much space for creativity and flexibility in how we apply them.

From: winning to extract value for an “owner” of an idea
To: diverse growth with shared value among many

So, rather than control nature with industrial laws as our forefathers have, the work of our generation is to bring natural dynamics back into the core of all our operating systems. Instead of a view on technology that seeks to control and extract, we need to allow nature to reverse-mentor us toward systems focused on regeneration, infinite diversity, life/death/life cycles.

“We’re awake now, and the question is how do we stay awake to the living world? How do we make the act of asking nature’s advice a normal part of everyday inventing?” — Janine Benyus, Co-founder of the Biomimicry Institute

Let’s take a deeper look at just a couple of ideas, some of nature’s butterflies:

  • The Golden Ratio: 1.618, from the Fibonacci sequence is everywhere in nature. From shells, flowers, fingerprints, cacti. Nature is so elegant and consistent that she designed a single pattern that inspires infinite diversity and creativity.
a winding staircase that mimics the golden ration
a sunflower that mimics the golden ratio
Ludde Lorentz, unsplash
  • Symbiosis: the idea of creating symbiotic systems where every element has a role that helps the other elements. ❤️🍃 Like the Three Sisters traditional planting system, where corn, beans, and squash are planted together. The corn provides structure for her sisters, beans infuse the soil with nitrogen, and the squash provides shade that limits weeds.

So how do we take a focus on ‘butterflies, not moonshots’ forward? I think there’s a few mindsets:

  • Intention: we move forward with a conscious intention to share more openly in creative commons, away from protective modes.
  • Humility: an ongoing mindfulness activity reminding ourselves that our new ideas are likely new revelations within our own knowledge of field, but likely already have root and substance.
  • Relationships, Not Objects: as designers, we can shift our attention to designing for better relationships, rather than perfecting objects.

As we imagine releasing butterflies into our worlds, we still strive to create large waves of impact. The ambition of bringing our hopes for the future directly into the present is needed to tackle the big challenges of our time— climate crisis, social inequity, economic transition. The butterfly mindset shift is simply a way of tempering our ambition with a lens of shared value and regeneration. A humbled, pollinator mindset.

The UX Collective donates US$1 for each article we publish. This story contributed to World-Class Designer School: a college-level, tuition-free design school focused on preparing young and talented African designers for the local and international digital product market. Build the design community you believe in.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

Written by Ariel Sim

Human Rights & Regenerative Design Fellow @ NYU School of Law

Responses (3)

Write a response

Thinking about technology education: the goal is not to nurture the next generation of Steve Jobs's, Ada Lovelace's, or Albert Einstein's - the goal is something much more distributed, democratic, organic. Butterfly Warriors.

--

Also, is Medium worth doing again? lol. I got turned off by their business model change a few years back.

--

Loveeee this Ariel.
So I’ve been thinking about the application of moonshot vs butterfly idea to the technology field. I hear this a lot in the more forward leaning tech people: “technology is not the solution, but a part of the solution”. There is…

--