Fascinations on mechanical keyboards

Typing on a keyboard is something that almost everyone is familiar with. People communicate using words typed on a keyboard more and more, especially due to the coronavirus pandemic. Apart from the simple need to communicate, most people work with a computer nowadays, and they use keyboard as a mean to interact with said computer. Although some people might think of keyboards as a means to end, I believe there are more to keyboards than just a typing machine — it’s a rather fascinating technology that we have today.

Fadhriga Bestari
UX Collective

--

Which Switch You Switched To?

Before I go on, I want to explain a little bit about what makes a mechanical keyboard a mechanical keyboard. It’s simple, really. Mechanical keyboards are keyboards that use a (mechanical) switch underneath each key. These switches provide mechanical keyboards with more durability and personalization than regular keyboards.

Generally, there are three types of switches used in mechanical keyboards:

  1. Clicky (Blue)
  2. Linear (Red)
  3. Tactile (Brown)
An animation showing how clicky (blue), linear (red), and tactile (brown) switches operates
https://www.penaddict.com/blog/2020/3/11/a-brief-introduction-to-mechanical-keyboard-switches

There is no coloring convention on different types of switches, though. Popular switch manufacturer like Cherry MX use this coloring convention, but there are other colors used for the same type of switches as well. For example, Razer use a new type of switch colors, i.e. green and purple. There are also manufacturer that provide a black and clear switches, each giving different typing sensations entirely.

Clicky Switches

People generally thinks of loud click sounding keyboards when they hear the mention of mechanical keyboards. This is because most mechanical keyboard (especially the old ones) are built using clicky switches. You may not believe this, but some people really enjoy the sound of click when they type. Clicky switches generally also have a higher force needed to be used to press on each key, leaving a more tangible feedback when you type on clicky mechanical keyboards.

An annoyed bird meme due to the clacking sound of mechanical keyboards

Linear Switches

Contrary to popular believes, there exists a type of keyboard that doesn’t have a loud, annoying sound. Mechanical keyboards that use a linear switch are silent and designed to have a very low actuation force. These keyboards are designed mostly for gamers. Due to the lower the actuation force, the faster your finger can input the key that you intended to press. I, myself find linear switches to be hard to use other than for gaming, because the low actuation force actually caused me to make a lot of typos when typing.

Tactile Switches

The tactile switch are the offspring of clicky and linear switches. It has a higher actuation force than linear switch, but it doesn’t produce as loud of a clicking sound as clicky switches. This is a good type of mechanical switch for people that doesn’t want to make a loud noise every time they type and want a higher actuation force when typing. Just a heads up, though, I find that the brown switch are hard to come by and mostly sold out in many cases.

In All Shapes and Sizes

Some people use numpad keys for putting in numbers, sure. Most available keyboard and mechanical keyboard offers numpad on their layout. Mechanical keyboard, though, appeals to different types of people and different types of use cases.

A full-sized mechanical keyboard

For people that rarely use numpads, they can choose the TKL mechanical keyboard.

A TKL mechanical keyboard; mechanical keyboards without numpads

If you want a smaller keyboard to make it easier to carry around, then you can pick a 75% mechanical keyboard.

A 75% mechanical keyboard; a more compact mechanical keyboard without numpads

Oh? You don’t need the function keys, you say? In that case, what about a 65% mechanical keyboard instead?

A 65% mechanical keyboard; mechanical keyboard without numpads and function keys

No need for arrow keys? Say no more fam.

A 60% mechanical keyboard; mechanical keyboard without numpads, function keys, and arrow keys

What? No numbers? I don’t thi — oh. Nevermind.

A 40% mechanical keyboard; mechanical keyboard without numpads, function keys, arrow keys, and even numbers

Keyboard for Mechanics

The biggest thing that separate a regular keyboard and a mechanical keyboard is how you can buy each part separately and build you own keyboard; from the chassis, to the switches, to which keycaps to use, and even to the lighting used on the keyboard. There is nothing better than using a piece of equipment that you build from the ground up, with every component you researched and handpicked yourself. I personally never build a mechanical keyboard because they cost up to around $600, but I assume the satisfaction ones get from building their own mechanical keyboards are similar to how I felt when I built my own PC.

Ain’t Nobody Got Money For That

Fascinating technologies come at a price. For this one, apparently worth as much as the minimum monthly wage in my country. Don’t let this discourage you, however, since there are many good mechanical keyboards available for under $100. In most cases, you pay a hefty price not for the utility (switches) and size of the keyboard, rather on the brand name and design of the keyboard. If you really want that red greek lettered keycap on a yellow chassis, though, you need to be prepared to empty your wallet.

Drake hotline bling meme choosing a $250 mechanical keyboard over a $14 regular keyboard

Mechanical keyboards provide a more versatile and personalized experience than regular keyboard. The expensive price tag is compensated by the utility, personalization, and satisfaction provided in both building and using a mechanical keyboard. Mechanical keyboards might not be for everyone, but it is certainly for me.

The UX Collective donates US$1 for each article published in our platform. This story contributed to Bay Area Black Designers: a professional development community for Black people who are digital designers and researchers in the San Francisco Bay Area. By joining together in community, members share inspiration, connection, peer mentorship, professional development, resources, feedback, support, and resilience. Silence against systemic racism is not an option. Build the design community you believe in.

--

--