UX Collective

We believe designers are thinkers as much as they are makers. https://linktr.ee/uxc

Follow publication

Figma vs. Adobe XD: How we picked our next design tool

Tomas Urlikas
UX Collective
Published in
11 min readJun 12, 2020

Image of Figma boxer against Adobe XD boxer in the ring
Associative illustration by Tomas Urlikas

The time came for changes and our design team started raising the topic again about how we should consider moving away from Sketch. This is not the first time this question came to mind, but this time seems like it was serious. Last summer we considered changing Sketch to something else, but at the time the decision was made that it is not worth the hassle. We decided to wait until this tool will catch up as some of us honestly believed in the future of it.

For Telesoftas designers it is a second revolution — the first big one was a long time ago a move from Photoshop to Sketch. At the time it seemed like an enormous deal and the progress of something revolutionary. Now this time we can call it the second design revolution and the next big change.

Prehistory of Sketch and why the change is needed

Timeline of Sketch App history when it was founded in 2004. Sketch App timeline showing all major updates
Photo from Slideshare.com by Jens Hoffmann

Most of the team got used to Sketch and it was a really praised tool at the beginning of transition. We were excited about how easy it is to use, sharing with others tips and tricks, shortcuts. What I liked about Sketch at first was symbols and how you can have nested symbols inside. It helped to save many hours; we improved consistency and sped up the entire workflow. However, while working on bigger projects I saw serious performance issues when Sketch started crashing often. Some work got lost and it was a tedious process which tested your nerves.

Collaboration was really a pain and for that you have to use plugins, other services to be in sync with other designers. It was not working perfectly and sometimes we were resolving conflicts when we tried to push designs to the service cloud from the plugin. That when a design tool requires so many other services to be functional at its minimalistic level is outrageous. For design sync we used Plant, for sharing designs with clients or PMs Invision, for creating animations Principle and for sharing with developers Sympli. Sometimes also Anima to create smart adaptive layouts. Since Sketch is the industry-standard tool the missing product features created a lot of opportunities for new businesses to arise.

Create an account to read the full story.

The author made this story available to Medium members only.
If you’re new to Medium, create a new account to read this story on us.

Or, continue in mobile web

Already have an account? Sign in

Written by Tomas Urlikas

User Experience Designer with a passion for researching people behaviour and experimenting on design techniques. Consistency is key and less is more.

Responses (12)

Write a response

Good comparison, Tomas. Thanks for sharing how you evaluated these tools.
Having used both these tools (among others), I think the standout feature in XD is its Component States feature, which eliminates the need for duplicating artboards and layers…

--

You didn’t mention the Easy access figma provide, Works in Browser, Which helps a lot in collaboration with developers/clients and saves their time installing some additional software.

--

Its close, Figma and XD… but adobe’s support for Android and Windows is disgraceful.
If you want to create a frame/ layout for an Android device in XD it’s ridiculous compared to Figma.
Previewing your prototypes on an actual device (besides iPhone)…

--