UX Collective

We believe designers are thinkers as much as they are makers. https://linktr.ee/uxc

Follow publication

Is this the death or dawn of human creativity?

Should we fear AI as a creativity villain or celebrate it as a creativity companion?

Ian Batterbee
UX Collective
Published in
7 min read5 days ago

An illustration shows a person facing toward the left while standing in the middle of a crowd of people, staring at their devices, moving in the opposite direction.
Which direction is AI leading humanity’s creativity? Yes, this cover was created by a human. Credit: Uran Duo.

My wife caught me cheating. But wait, it’s not what you think.

In the corner of her eye, she saw me using generative AI. “Isn’t that cheating?” she asked. After a slightly awkward pause, I tried to justify my actions.

In my carefully crafted response, I explained I was using “a smart robot helper” to automate some tasks. It was like having an extra brain to handle some heavy lifting. This way, I would spend more quality moments with her.

Well, I didn’t quite say the last part. Still, I explained that using generative AI enhances my workflow and even opens new windows of opportunity.

My wife’s playful accusation hinted at a profound truth: Many people wonder if using AI is somehow “cheating.” This sparked my reflection: Should we fear AI diminishing our creativity or embrace it as an enhancer of our ingenuity?

There are different perspectives on this argument. Sceptics will tell you that AI erodes human creativity. At the same time, the fearful will portray AI as an apocalyptic SkyNet future. That’s understandable, given the doomsday science fiction stories like The Matrix, The Terminator, and Ex Machina.

A dog wearing a hat sits at a table drinking coffee while the room goes up in flames.
I saw the irony in this AI-generated version of Web comic artist KC Green’s “This is Fine” meme. Credit: Luis C.

Fear and prejudice toward technology are not new phenomena either. Just as people once criticised the introduction of the first calculators, we now see individuals keying Teslas for political reasons. Emotions and values often shape people’s perspectives, which is encapsulated in the phrase popularised by psychologist Jonathan Haidt: “The emotional tail wags the rational dog.”

However, those who embrace AI see it as a tool that enhances creativity and empowers human potential, unlike the sceptics and the fearful.

It’s natural to reject change or something that conflicts with our values. But when we choose not to consider the full context, we miss out on the benefits that can drastically enhance our quality of living.

Create an account to read the full story.

The author made this story available to Medium members only.
If you’re new to Medium, create a new account to read this story on us.

Or, continue in mobile web

Already have an account? Sign in

Written by Ian Batterbee

I analyse and write about the value of UX Design and meaningful innovation. Follow me for regular thoughts and frameworks.

Responses (9)

Write a response

This is helpful thinking. When the telegraph came out, some said it would result in the death of poetry. History shows that when revolutionary technologies come out and when constraints are put on creativity, humans actually get more creative. AI is…

--

Miro, Notion, and Trello embrace AI to simplify complex data into actionable insights, visualise workflows, and provide fresh perspectives on opportunities and challenges

I'd argue that these tools a form os bureaucracy that leads not to creativity, but rather to conforming to social norms.

--

Should we fear AI diminishing our creativity or embrace it as an enhancer of our ingenuity?

I am using AI to enhance my work flow and for productivity purposes. AI doesn't diminish our creativity if strategize on using it. It can only enhance and amplify our creative potentials

--