UX Collective

We believe designers are thinkers as much as they are makers. https://linktr.ee/uxc

Follow publication

Member-only story

This is NOT collaboration

Michal Malewicz
UX Collective
Published in
7 min readOct 25, 2020

where teams design together — spoof

Yes, this is going to be one of those controversial articles, and if you’re a Figma superfan, you likely want to start throwing rocks at me right now. Am I right? But please hold off for a while, and hear me out.

Collaboration is…

Starting my design career in the late ’90s, collaboration simply meant someone sitting behind your shoulder at a clunky grey PC, and pointing at the screen.

“Move that here!” and then “No, that’s too far…”

Collaboration in design of the early 2000's

Our CRT monitors got smudges where the fingers pointed, so the more smudged the display was, the more feedback someone had received. You could almost call each fingerprint a modern-day “Figma comment”.

But we’ve gone pretty far since then. The design tools evolved from the Adobe-only days, with first Sketch, and then Figma showing designers completely new ways to work.

three people making a sandwich in Figma
Three people making one sandwich may be a good idea — on paper.

Currently, collaboration is a hot topic. It’s been considered the best innovation since sliced bread.

Nearly every Figma user I talked to, says they prefer this tool because of the great collaboration features it has. I’d bet that the free plan and OS independence (Sketch is Mac only) has a little more to do with this, but I understand why not many people want to admit to those reasons.

They even made collaboration the main marketing message at Figma.com

figma website header — where teams design together
Yeah, I don’t see any difference between this and my main image either ;)

How to show collaboration?

I believe this is an incorrect approach to show collaboration. Why?

Create an account to read the full story.

The author made this story available to Medium members only.
If you’re new to Medium, create a new account to read this story on us.

Or, continue in mobile web

Already have an account? Sign in

Write a response

Personally, I don't believe in design collaboration — certainly not in the way it is now so hotly pushed upon us.
I believe in finding the right experts to do what they do best and giving them the authority and trust to design and solve the UI/UX…

--

All reported problems have more to do with the maturity of the team and manager, than with the tool and the functionality of collaboration.
It seems like a fallacious argument to me!

--

Admittedly I am a huge Figma fan.. And I think you make a lot of fantastic points here. That said, within our team we are very careful around when we use Figma’s collaboration features. We also have a pretty robust design system that we all adhere…

--