When to trust your gut over the data
How cultural conformity influences user preferences.
Data is a fascinating tool. For example, it shows that most spiders we encounter are harmless. Yet, this doesn’t stop the instinctual fear we feel when one crawls across our wall at night. This fear is deeply rooted in evolution — early humans who were cautious of potentially dangerous creatures, like venomous spiders, had a better chance of survival, even though most spiders pose no real threat.
Similarly, while design choices don’t endanger us like a poisonous spider, trusting our instincts in design decisions is crucial. Our gut feelings often cut through the noise of data, helping us make intuitive, human-centered choices that emotionally resonate and uncover insights that pure data lacks.
Short-Term Effectiveness vs. Long-Term Potential
Minimalism has become one of the most dominant trends in modern design, whether it’s websites, apps, or branding. Sleek, simple designs with ample white space and minimal text are ubiquitous. They communicate sophistication, modernity, and ease of use.
Data has played a significant role in driving minimalism forward. Most research indicates users appreciate clean, uncluttered designs. Regarding websites and digital products, objectives such as conversion rates, click-throughs, and time spent on pages suggest minimalism works.
The issue with minimalism isn’t its effectiveness — it undoubtedly succeeds, especially in the short term. The deeper challenge, however, lies in its limitations in fully realizing and expressing the broader, long-term potential of design, often restricting the depth and richness of meaning that more intuitive approaches can unlock.
An example of a recent design that followed minimalist trends and data instead of intuition is PayPal’s brand refresh — which also sparked mixed reactions. For some, the redesign felt like a regression — a stripping away of the brand’s character in favor of sterile simplicity. Others, however, lauded the move, seeing it as a way to project clarity and focus.
What makes debates like this particularly compelling is how people respond to critiques of brand refreshes — especially when a minimalist approach is challenged. These criticisms are often brushed aside with the predictable defense: “The data supports it.”
In the face of trends like minimalism, it’s worth questioning whether data reveals authentic user preferences or merely reflects cultural conformity. Do users prefer these designs, or are they conditioned to expect them to be the norm?
Cultural Pressure and the Asch Conformity Experiments
The influence of cultural conformity is profound. The Asch conformity experiments, conducted in the 1950s, demonstrated how individuals often conform to the majority opinion, even when it contradicts their own perceptions.
In the experiment, participants were shown a series of lines and asked to match one with another of similar length. What they didn’t know was that the other participants were in on the experiment and deliberately gave incorrect answers. Despite clearly knowing better, many participants conformed and also gave the wrong response.
How does this apply to design? Cultural pressure can play a similar role in shaping user preferences. If minimalism has become the dominant aesthetic, users may prefer it simply because it’s what they see everywhere. They may subconsciously conform to the idea that “this is what good design looks like” without questioning whether it genuinely resonates with them.
The Problem with Over-Reliance on Data
Data, while invaluable, can be tainted by this kind of cultural pressure. When conducting user research, it’s essential to consider that people may not always provide authentic feedback. Instead, they might offer responses that align with what they think they’re supposed to like.
Suppose the majority of the web and branding world is pushing minimalism. In that case, users may default to preferring that style — even if, deep down, they don’t find it as engaging or memorable as something bolder.
This conformity creates a problem. If designers and branding experts rely solely on user feedback or data, they risk perpetuating trends that might not resonate with people on a deeper level. The result is designs and brands that feel impersonal, uninspired, and, eventually, indistinguishable from one another — which is what we’ve been witnessing over the last few years.
The Limits of Data in Design Decisions
One significant limitation of data is that it often reflects only the present moment. Trends can skew the results, making it hard to discern whether a design truly resonates or simply conforms to current norms. Data-driven design tends to rely on short-term feedback, often missing a design’s long-lasting emotional impact.
For instance, a simple, minimalist interface might lead to high user satisfaction in the immediate term because it’s familiar and easy to navigate. But over time, users may find it boring, repetitive, or lacking in character. Data doesn’t always capture that kind of long-term engagement or the potential for a design to become memorable and emotionally meaningful.
The Value of Expert Intuition in Design
This is where expert intuition becomes invaluable. Experienced designers and branding professionals have a deep understanding of not just what works but why it works. They’ve seen trends come and go and developed a keen sense of when to follow them and break away. Intuition, honed through years of practice, can help cut through the noise of current trends and data to identify what will truly resonate with people.
Take Steve Jobs, for example. Apple’s success didn’t come from simply following the data. Jobs famously disregarded focus groups and market research, relying instead on his intuition about what people wanted — even when they didn’t express it themselves. The result was a series of revolutionary products that fundamentally changed how we interact with technology. Of course, not everyone is Steve Jobs. The point is that successful design is possible without overly relying on data.
When to Trust Your Gut Over Data
Data has its place, and designers shouldn’t abandon it entirely. However, there are specific scenarios where gut instinct should take precedence over data. One such scenario is when a trend like minimalism becomes so dominant that it begins to influence the very data it produces. In these cases, intuition can help designers break free from the constraints of conformity and create something truly innovative.
Another scenario is when data points to a solution that feels uninspired or generic — as in the case of PayPal. If a design feels soulless, even though the numbers support it, that’s a sign that it may not have the lasting emotional impact needed to resonate with users. Intuition, guided by experience and creativity, can help fill that gap.
Crafting Authentic Design Solutions
To craft designs that genuinely resonate, designers need to strike a balance between data and intuition. Data provides valuable insights but should be viewed as one tool among many, not the sole guide. Expert intuition can help identify when a design trend, like minimalism, no longer serves its purpose and when it’s time to innovate.
In recent years, maximalist web designs have emerged as a bold counter to the minimalist trends that dominated much of the digital landscape. These designs thrive on complexity, layering vibrant colors, intricate patterns, and dynamic animations to create a sense of depth and personality. This shift taps into a desire for more expressive and emotionally engaging experiences, offering something fresh and visually impactful.
To Sum it Up
Data is an essential tool in design, but it’s not infallible. When trends like minimalism dominate, they can skew user feedback and create the illusion of preference. The Asch conformity experiments teach us that people often conform to what they see around them, which can lead to tainted data. In these cases, expert intuition becomes a crucial guide. By trusting your gut, experienced designers can cut through trends and create designs that truly resonate, crafting solutions that aren’t just trendy but also meaningful and memorable.
Don’t miss out! Join my email list and receive the latest content.
